ST. LOUIS, MO (STL.News) - As 2025 reaches its midpoint, conflicting narratives about the U.S. economy have created a widening gap between what official numbers report and how everyday Americans are experiencing the world around them. While economic data suggests a picture of modest growth and stability, the reality on the ground tells a different story – one of business closures, a frozen housing market, and inflation that continues to erode household budgets.
This growing disconnect has led to skepticism, frustration, and a rising chorus of voices questioning whether traditional economic indicators truly reflect the state of the nation’s economy.
According to the latest government data, the U.S. economy appears to be on solid footing:
From a macroeconomic standpoint, these numbers imply stability and resilience. Yet that’s not what’s being felt across American cities and towns.
While Wall Street might be booming, Main Street is bruising. Across the U.S., small business closures are becoming alarmingly common. In cities like St. Louis, once-thriving restaurants, local retailers, and service-based businesses are shuttering their doors after struggling to recover from the pandemic and inflationary spikes of the early 2020s.
Several factors are contributing to this ongoing contraction:
Compounding the problem is that many of these small businesses rely on a healthy housing market to drive consumer confidence and local investment. But that market, too, is paralyzed.
Despite efforts by the Federal Reserve to stabilize the housing sector, the real estate market in 2025 is caught in a deep freeze. Mortgage rates remain elevated, hovering around 6.5% to 7%, making homes increasingly unaffordable, especially for first-time buyers.
On the other hand, existing homeowners who locked in low mortgage rates before 2022 are reluctant to sell and face significantly higher payments on a new property. This has created a lock-in effect, stifling both supply and demand.
The result?
Even though home prices are no longer soaring, the lack of movement in the market is keeping people stuck, unable to buy, sell, or relocate for better opportunities.
The Federal Reserve and government economists may claim inflation is under control, but for American households, the damage is already done.
Prices for everyday goods – groceries, rent, insurance, gas, healthcare, and childcare – are still dramatically higher than they were just a few years ago. While inflation rates may have slowed, the cumulative effect on household budgets has been devastating.
Wages, meanwhile, have not kept pace with the rising cost of living. Many workers are earning slightly more, but their dollars don’t go as far. This has forced families to make difficult decisions:
In fact, credit card debt is at an all-time high, with rising delinquencies signaling growing financial distress among consumers.
With inflation persisting and uncertainty looming, consumers are adjusting their spending habits. Retail spending has shifted:
For businesses, especially small retailers and restaurants, this shift in spending is another blow. They’re facing higher costs and lower traffic, a combination that’s forcing many to scale back, downsize, or shut down entirely.
The contradiction between what government economists report and what Americans feel is fueling distrust in institutions and headlines. Here’s why the data doesn’t match the experience:
In essence, official numbers are lagging indicators that often fail to capture the nuances of daily financial strain, especially for the working and middle classes.
While the U.S. may not be in a technical recession by textbook definitions, many believe we are in a “vibecession” – a term used to describe an economy that is statistically fine but feels like a downturn to the majority.
If economic policymakers want to restore confidence, they’ll need to stop celebrating abstract stability and start addressing the real pain points Americans face every day. Until then, the disconnect between data and reality will only grow wider.
STL.News will continue to report on the evolving economic conditions and their impact on businesses, homeowners, and families in the St. Louis area.
If you have experienced a business closure or are facing economic hardship, please reach out to our newsroom – we’re here to listen.
{“uri”:“stl.news”,“dataType”:“news”,“title”:“STL.News”,“description”:“STL.News offers St Louis News, Breaking News, Latest News and News Videos. STL.News publishes unbiased direct source news.”}stl.news